August 2014,Seminar on elevation of judge’s criteria

August 2014

Seminar on elevation of judge’s criteria

Seminar on elevation of judge’s criteria was organized by the Mubashir Bhutta Human Rights trust and protecting civil liberties and civil rights large munber of lawyers and members from civil society participated including ,Mr.saviuddin awan advocate and shafeq advocate participated and addressed to the audience .While addressing Mubashir Bhutta advocate expressed that,

Seniority is an important consideration in the elevation of judges, as it can help to ensure that the most experienced and qualified judges are appointed to higher positions. The seniority rule is a common practice in many countries and jurisdictions, including Pakistan, and it is based on the principle that judges who have served for a longer period of time have gained more experience, knowledge, and judgment than those who are relatively new to the profession.

One of the key advantages of following the seniority rule in the elevation of judges is that it can help to maintain stability and predictability in the judiciary. By adhering to a clear and consistent promotion policy, judges are able to plan their careers and have a clear understanding of how they can advance within the judiciary.

Moreover, the seniority rule can help to prevent political interference in the appointment process, as it is less susceptible to manipulation and lobbying than other appointment criteria. Seniority is a neutral and objective criterion that can be easily measured, and it does not depend on personal or political connections.

However, it is also important to note that seniority alone should not be the sole criterion for the elevation of judges. Other factors, such as performance, qualifications, and judicial temperament, should also be considered. Seniority should be one of several factors that are taken into account in the elevation process, and it should not be viewed as a guarantee of promotion.

In conclusion, while the seniority rule can be an important consideration in the elevation of judges, it should not be the sole criterion. A balanced and objective promotion policy that takes into account various factors, including seniority, performance, qualifications, and judicial temperament, can help to ensure that the most qualified and capable judges are appointed to higher positions, and that the judiciary remains independent and impartial.